For Pat Trotter, the 12th time’s the charm

“No matter how hard we try and how much we think we know, there is always something to learn.” – "Born to Win" by Patricia Craige Trotter

Photo courtesy of Mary Bloom

By Denise Flaim
Over the past 50 years, Patricia V. Trotter of Carmel, California, has stepped into the finale at Westminster 11 times with one of her world-famous Vin-Melca Norwegian Elkhounds. And on each occasion she left the ring without the breathtaking Best in Show rosette.
But in February, Trotter will return for the dozenth time — as the 2021 Westminster Kennel Club Best in Show judge.
"This time I won't have my own dog to lean on," she says of the role reversal. "But I will have seven wonderful dogs to focus on that have been sent on by very knowledgeable and respected judges. When dogs get to that Best in Show finale, they're all superstars."

Trotter judging Longhaired Dachshunds at the Garden in 2008. Photo courtesy Mary Bloom.

Trotter's almost-dozen Group wins at Westminster spanned 1970 to 2017, with every one of those Elkhounds related to each other. Indeed, all her dogs descend from her foundation bitch, acquired in 1949 from an accomplished bear hunter. In the 1970s, half of the Westminster Hound Group winners were Vin-Melca Elkhounds. Trotter's breeding program produced the top sire and dam in breed history as well as 39 different Best in Show winners, and she handled Top 10 all-breed dogs on 10 different occasions — all while working as a teacher full time.
But Trotter considers her greatest Westminster accomplishment to be taking a relatively unknown breed to such heights at the nation's — and perhaps the world's — most high-profile show. "An amazingly happy surprise," she muses, thinking back to her first-ever Westminster win in 1970 with Vagabond.

Best in Show judge Anna Katherine Nicholas walks the lineup at Westminster in 1970, the first year Trotter won the Hound Group at the Garden. From left, Corky Vroom with Pointer Ch. Counterpoint’s Lord Ashley, Pat Trotter (then Craige) with Norwegian Elkhound Ch. Vin Melca’s Vagabond, Jane Forsyth with Boxer Ch. Arriba’s Prima Donna, Ric Chashoudian with Wire Fox Terrier Ch. Holmwire Reliants, Harry Classen with Boston Terrier Ch. Star Q’s Brass Buttons and Frank Sabella with Pekingese Ch. Beaupres Tomsjoy Lea Chim"Suzie" the Boxer was ultimately victorious.

Two of Trotter's Group-winning Westminster dogs were mother and daughter — Ch. Vin-Melca's Calista and Marketta, respectively. Each won the group there twice — likely a record for that venue.
An all-breed judge who has judged at the Garden four times before — including the Hound Groups in 2009 and 2019 — Trotter is also in great demand as a national-specialty judge. Doubtless this has to do with her reputation as a "breeder's breeder": Trotter bred her first litter in 1951, and her most recent this year. And, fittingly, her conversation with this reporter came to an end when a call regarding shipping frozen semen buzzed in on the other line.

Vin-Melca Westminster Group Winners
1970 and 1971 • Ch. Vin Melca's Vagabond
1974 • Ch. Vin-Melca's Homesteader
1977 and 1979 • Ch. Vin-Melca's Nimbus
1986 • Ch.Vin-Melca's Call to Arms
1989 and 1990 • Ch. Vin-Melca's Calista
1994 and 1995 • Ch. Vin-Melca's Marketta (pictured with Group judge Lee Canalizo in 1994)
2017 • GCh. Vin-Melca’s Daggarwood Delight

Not merely focused on bringing her carefully curated line of dogs into the world, Trotter is also intent on keeping them here. "I value longevity in my dogs," she says. "And I truly respect the concept of preserving the breed that was passed on to us by master breeders of the past."
After kicking off the Vin-Melca legacy at Westminster in 1970, Vagabond returned at the age of 14 in a parade of champions for previous Group and Best in Show winners. (He's pictured here on that day.) Trotter remembers announcer Roger Caras saying that as far as he knew, Vagabond was the oldest dog ever to walk onto the floor of Madison Square Garden. He lived to be 17.

Chuck and Pat Trotter ringside at the Morris & Essex Kennel Club show.
 Photo courtesy of Mary Bloom.

With all her wins at Westminster, Trotter is keenly aware of the crackling energy that suffuses the Best in Show ring on Tuesday night. "It's electric, and so very exciting," she says of her times exhibiting there.
Will the sparks fly just as brightly when one is judging the dogs rather than presenting them?
"You better believe it!" Trotter responds with a laugh. "And I'm looking forward to it."

2021 Westminster Group and Breed Judges
Hound GroupMr. Jamie Hubbard of Bloomington, IN
Ms. Pamela Bruce of Welland, Ontario, Canada: American English Coonhounds, American Foxhounds, Black and Tan Coonhounds, Bloodhounds, Bluetick Coonhounds, Cirnechi dell'Etna, English Foxhounds, Norwegian Elkhounds, Otterhounds, Redbone Coonhounds, Treeing Walker Coonhounds.Hon. James G. Phinizy of Acworth, NH: Irish Wolfhounds, Scottish Deerhounds.Mrs. Jan Swayze- Curry of Columbia, KY: Afghan Hounds, Dachshunds (all Varieties).Mr. Harold Tatro, III of Crowley, TX: Azawakhs, Borzois, Greyhounds, Ibizan Hounds, Pharaoh Hounds, Salukis, Sloughis, Whippets.Ms. Bonnie P. Threlfall of Cary, NC: Harriers, Plotts, Portuguese Podengo Pequenos, Rhodesian Ridgebacks.Mrs. Robyn Joy Wallis of Victoria, Australia: Basenjis, Basset Hounds, Beagles (both Varieties), Grand Basset Griffon Vendéens, Petit Basset Griffon Vendéens. Toy GroupMrs. June A. Penta of Greensburg, PA
Mr. Sei-ichiro Ishimaru of Tokyo, Japan: Brussels Griffons, Chinese Cresteds, English Toy Spaniels (both Varieties), Havanese, Italian Greyhounds, Japanese Chin, Shih Tzu, Toy Manchester Terriers.Ms. Evalyn Gregory of Louisville, KY: Affenpinschers, Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, Maltese, Miniature Pinschers, Toy Fox Terriers.Mr. Glen Lajeski of Cloverdale, CA: Papillons, Pekingese, Pomeranians, Toy Poodles.Mr. George Milutinovich of Fresno, CA: Chihuahuas (both Varieties), Pugs, Silky Terriers, Yorkshire Terriers.
Non-Sporting GroupDr. John A. Reeve-Newson of Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Mr. Johan Becerra-Hernandez of San Juan, Puerto Rico: Bichon Frises, Chow Chows, Lowchen, Norwegian Lundehunds, Shiba Inu, Tibetan Terriers, Xoloitzcuintlis.Mr. Carl E. Gomes of Bronx, NY: Boston Terriers, Finnish Spitz.Ms. Evalyn Gregory of Louisville, KY: Dalmatians, Lhasa Apsos, Tibetan Spaniels.Mr. David J. Kirkland of Sanford, NC: Bulldogs, French Bulldogs.Mr. Glen Lajeski of Cloverdale, CA: Miniature Poodles, Standard Poodles.Mrs. Molly Martin of Pike Road, AL: American Eskimo Dogs, Chinese Shar-Pei, Cotons de Tulear, Keeshonden, Schipperkes.
Herding GroupMr. William P. Shelton of Pomona, CA
Mr. Johan Becerra-Hernandez of San Juan, Puerto Rico: Bearded Collies, Border Collies, German Shepherd Dogs.Mr. Dana P. Cline of Hodges, SC: Australian Cattle Dogs, Bouvier des Flanders, Collies (both Varieties), Entlebucher Mountain Dogs, Finnish Lapphunds, Pulik, Pumik, Pyrenean Shepherds, Shetland Sheepdogs, Spanish Water Dogs, Swedish Vallhunds.Mr. David J. Kirkland of Sanford, NC: Australian Shepherds, Belgian Laekenois, Miniature American Shepherds.Mrs. Sheree Moses Combs of Wardensville, WV: Beaucerons, Bergamasco Sheepdogs, Berger Picards, Briards, Canaan Dogs, Icelandic Sheepdogs, Norwegian Buhunds, Old English Sheepdogs, Polish Lowland Sheepdogs.Ms. Sharon Ann Redmer of Whitmore Lake, MI: Belgian Malinois, Belgian Sheepdogs, Belgian Tervuren, Cardigan Welsh Corgis, Pembroke Welsh Corgis.
Sporting GroupMr. Frank Kane of North Yorkshire, United Kingdom
Ms. Pamela Bruce of Welland, Ontario, Canada: American Water Spaniels, Boykin Spaniels, Clumber Spaniels, Cocker Spaniels (all Varieties), English Cocker Spaniels, English Springer Spaniels Field Spaniels, Irish Water Spaniels, Sussex Spaniels, Welsh Springer Spaniels.Mr. Dan Ericsson of Enkoping, Sweden: Golden Retrievers, Labrador Retrievers.Mr. David L. Kittredge of Rochester, NY: Barbets, Brittanys, Lagotti Romagnoli, Nederlandse Kooikerhondjes, Pointers, Vizslas, Weimaraners, Wirehaired Pointing Griffons, Wirehaired Vizslas.Ms. Bonnie P. Threlfall of Cary, NC: Chesapeake Bay Retrievers, Curly-Coated Retrievers, Flat-Coated Retrievers, Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retrievers, Spinoni Italiani.Mrs. Robyn Joy Wallis of Victoria, Australia: English Setters, German Shorthaired Pointers, German Wirehaired Pointers, Gordon Setters, Irish Setters, Irish Red and White Setters.
Working GroupMs. Judy A. Harrington of Monson, MAMr. Johan Becerra-Hernandez of San Juan, Puerto Rico: Bernese Mountain Dogs, Doberman Pinschers, Dogo Argentinos, Newfoundlands, Samoyeds.Mr. Dana P. Cline of Hodges, SC: Akitas, Alaskan Malamutes, Anatolian Shepherd Dogs, Cane Corsos, Komondorok, Kuvaszok, Leonbergers, Neapolitan Mastiffs, Rottweilers, Saint Bernards, Tibetan Mastiffs.Ms. Evalyn Gregory of Louisville, KY: Boxers.Mr. David J. Kirkland of Sanford, NC: Giant Schnauzers, Standard Schnauzers.Mr. Glen Lajeski of Cloverdale, CA: Bullmastiffs, German Pinschers, Great Danes, Mastiffs.Ms. Kimberly Anne Meredith of Pleasant Hill, CA: Black Russian Terriers, Boerboels, Chinooks, Great Pyrenees, Portuguese Water Dogs, Siberian Huskies.Ms. Sharon Ann Redmer of Whitmore Lake, MI: Dogues de Bordeaux, Greater Swiss Mountain Dogs.
Terrier GroupMr. William Potter of St. Louis, MO
Mr. Dan Ericsson of Enkoping, Sweden: Airedale Terriers, American Staffordshire Terriers, Bull Terriers (both Varieties), Smooth Fox Terriers, Wire Fox Terriers, Parson Russell Terriers, Rat Terriers, Russell Terriers, Scottish Terriers, Sealyham Terriers, West Highland White Terriers.Mr. David J. Kirkland of Sanford, NC: Miniature Schnauzers.Mrs. Knowlton A. Reynders of Newbury, NH: American Hairless Terriers, Australian Terriers, Bedlington Terriers, Cairn Terriers, Cesky Terriers, Dandie Dinmont Terriers, Glen of Imaal Terriers, Irish Terriers, Miniature Bull Terriers, Norfolk Terriers, Norwich Terriers, Skye Terriers, Staffordshire Bull Terriers, Standard Manchester Terriers, Welsh Terriers.Ms. Bonnie P. Threlfall of Cary, NC: Border Terriers, Kerry Blue Terriers, Lakeland Terriers, Soft Coated Wheaten Terriers.

Click here to sign up for more Dog News@home newsletters.

 ‌  ‌

Have a story, suggestion or photo to share with Dog News?Send it to

Leave a Reply