Where Are They Now?
When you’ve reached the pinnacle of success – which for many in our world means winning Best in Show at Westminster – retirement is the logical next step. Though most previous Garden winners from recent years have disappeared from the ring – and some, sadly but inevitably, from the lives of the owners with whom they spent their final years – their presence stands eternally in the records books. Here are the last 10 Westminster Best in Show winners and where they are today.
GCH. Foxcliffe Hickory Wind
Owners: Sally Sweatt, Cecilia L. Dove and Dr. R. Scott Dove
Breeders: Cecilia L. and Dr. R. Scott Dove
Handler: Angela Lloyd
Judge: Paolo Dondina
After becoming the first-ever Deerhound to go Best in Show at the Garden, “Hickory” returned as a celebrity to Virginia hunt country, where everyone appreciates a good hound and the local tavern hosted a welcome-home party that was filled to the rafters.
Hickory spent her days on the Doves’ farm in Rappahannock County in a far more low-key fashion, “going out with her pack of about five to seven Deerhounds on the farm, wading in rivers, coursing whatever, chasing squirrels, lounging on her throne!” says breeder-owner Cecilia Dove.
After the obligatory post-show publicity rounds – from garden tours to horse shows – Hickory settled down for the inevitable next act: Her New Yorkers-themed litter was whelped at the end of 2011, followed by The Classics litter in 2013. “Several of her children were top Deerhounds, winning multiple breed shows, the national and regional specialties as well as the Breed Show in the U.K.,” Dove says. “Two daughters from her second litter were the top Deerhounds in both the U.K. and the U.S.A!”
Hickory died in 2017 at 11½ years old. “Hickory was a treasure,” Dove says, “a gift, loved deeply never to be forgotten!”
GCH. Palacegarden Malachy
Owners: Iris Love, Sandra Middlebrooks and David Fitzpatrick
Breeders: Jim and Jean Smith
Handler: David Fitzpatrick
Judge: Cindy Vogels
Nothing matters more than knowing who you are. While press accounts after his Garden win compared him to a troll doll, a Wookie, even – the deepest cut of all – Snooki from “Jersey Shore” – Malachy continued to move through the world with the dignity and gravitas that has defined his palace-dwelling forebears for millennia. It was this unshakeable sense of self that owner-handler David Fitzpatrick says Malachy possessed from the moment he walked out of the crate at Newark Airport as a 4-month-old British import.
After the Garden, Malachy returned home to East Berlin, Pennsylvania, with Fitzpatrick to become “the ruler of the roost.” His canine co-habitants might be playing or romping, “but when Malachy walked through the crowd, it was like the seas parting,” Fitzpatrick says. “He commanded the respect of the whole household. They just knew – he was the king. They’ve never done that for any other dog.”
Malachy died in 2017 at the age of nine, and Fitzpatrick says he was characteristically stoic to the end. “He was a fabulous character, and just a real gentleman.”
GCH. Banana Joe V Tani Kazari
Owners: Zoila Truesdale and Mieke Cooymans
Breeders: Mieke Cooymans
Handler: Ernesto Lara
Judge: Michael J. Dougherty
America may be the land of milk and honey, but not all immigrants choose to stay. That was the case with Netherlands-born Banana Joe, who after becoming the first-ever Affenpinscher to scale the heights of a Westminster Best in Show returned home to live with his breeder-owner Mieke Cooymans.
After sharing Joe with the world for three years – he can respond to commands in English, Dutch, Spanish and German – Cooymans was delighted to have him on her side of the Atlantic. “He remembered everything, even his buddies,” says Cooymans, whose primary job is spoiling him with abandon. That includes a serving of spaghetti once a week, as well as a weekly scoop of Ben & Jerry’s ice cream.
Today, at age 14, Joe may have lost some teeth, “but he’s still the handsome devil he always was,” Cooymans says. “Like Sean Connery, charm comes with age, and Joe has never lost it.”
GCH. Afterall Painting The Sky
Wire Fox Terrier
Owners: Victor Malzoni, Jr., Torie Steele, Scott and Mary Olund, and Diane Ryan
Breeders: A. J. Pertuit, Jr. and Betty Seton
Handler: Gabriel Rangel
Judge: Betty Regina Leininger
After her big Westminster win in 2014, Sky returned to the home of her longtime owner Diane Ryan, who had chosen her as a puppy because she had always wanted a ginger Wire Fox Terrier. But Ryan eventually determined that adding Sky back into her household would pose its challenges – Sky is a “princess” who is not always happy to share her space with other dogs, notes her handler Gabriel Rangel. So Sky went to live with Rangel, who had started showing her as a yearling puppy and has lived with Sky for most of her life.
Later this month, Sky will mark her 13th birthday at the Rangel home in Rialto, California. Last year’s celebration included an elaborately decorated birthday cake. Rangel groomed Sky up just as impeccably, and took photographs of both stunning confections before Sky was permitted to dig in.
“She really went for it. She was eating it like crazy,” Rangel says of the cake. “She got it all over the place – we didn’t get any of it.” Such is life with a terrier.
Ch. Tashtins Lookin For Trouble
Beagle (15 inch)
Owners: Eddie Dziuk, Lori Crandlemire and Kaitlyn Crandlemire
Breeder: Lori Crandlemire
Handler: William Alexander
Judge: Hon. David Merriam
In case you didn’t know, the “P” in “Miss P” stands for Peyton, although during her show career handler William Alexander liked to joke that “Princess” was more apt.
“It’s all about her. She’s so demanding,” Alexander told curious reporters at the time. "She thinks she’s the biggest dog in the dog show.”
After her 2015 triumph – only the second time a Beagle won Best at the Garden, on the heels of her great-uncle Uno’s win seven years earlier – Miss P retired with her breeder/owner Lori Crandlemire in British Columbia, Canada. There, she shares her life with two Doberman Pinschers and a bunch of Beagles.
Motherhood – natch – was on the docket, and co-owner Eddie Dziuk has one of her sons, “who I adore and who reminds me of his famed dam on a daily basis.”
The plucky Miss P celebrated her 10th birthday in January, and Crandlemire reports she still acts like a youngster – even outrunning her Beagle pack at home.
GCH Vjk-Myst Garbonita’s California Journey
German Shorthaired Pointer
Owners: Valerie Nunes-Atkinson, Alice Manning, Yvonne Hassler-Deterding, and Mark and Laurie Ulrich
Breeders: Alice Manning, Anita Weiss and Valerie Nunes-Atkinson Handler: Valerie Nunes-Atkinson
Judge: Dr. Richard Meen
Backward glances can be bittersweet. That’s the case with “CJ,” who at a mere three years old became the third German Shorthaired Pointer to win top honors at the Garden, following his grandmother Carlee’s win in 2005.
The charismatic CJ enjoyed an active post-show life with breeder-owner-handler Valerie Nunes-Atkinson of Temecula, California, running around the manicured paddocks with his friend Ramona the Whippet, starring in advertisements for the joint supplement Cosequin, and good-naturedly tolerating dress-up play sessions with her children.
But in the middle of last year, 7-year-old C.J. started showing some baffling symptoms, including lameness, neck soreness and blood in his urine. After a month and a half of extensive testing, he was diagnosed with cryptococcus, a fungal disease transmitted by some species of birds. The invisible spores entered his body and attacked his central nervous system. The last two weeks of his life CJ presented with lymphoma, which had taken hold after the cryptococcus infection weakened immune system.
CJ passed last September with Nunes-Atkinson, her son Garrett, Ramona the Whippet and his feline friend Tootsie at his side. “Goodbyes hurt the most when the story wasn’t finished,” Nunes-Atkinson wrote in a tribute published in this magazine about the dog she described as an “old soul.” He lives on in his progeny, which in the limited time he was at stud include the number-one GSPs in the U.SA., Australia and the top dog all breeds in Mexico – all from different dams.
GCH Lockenhaus’ Rumor Has It V Kenlyn
German Shepherd Dog
Owners: D. Stern, P. Buckles, P. Dukeman, P. McElheny and Kent Boyles
Breeders: Pamela McElheny and Kent Boyles
Handler: Kent Boyles
Judge: Thomas Bradley 3d
Retirement comes easy for some show dogs, but not for others. You can count Rumor in the latter group: For a solid six months after returning home to Edgerton, Wisconsin, after her 2017 Westminster Best in Show, breeder-owner Kent Boyles says his German Shepherd would “go out of her mind whenever I was packing my clothes or the truck.”
The only solution? Rumor rode shotgun to and from the shows.
Motherhood, thankfully, has made her more of a homebody. Rumor has had two litters since retiring from the ring. Boyles donated four puppies from her first litter of eight to a service-dog organization, with two of them going on to live with veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder.
Now almost 10 years old, Rumor still “gets her nose out of joint” whenever he is training a new prospect, Boyles reports. But given that her current favorite activity is snoozing on the bed, it appears she’s come to the conclusion that retirement does have its advantages.
GCHP Belle Creek’s All I Care About Is Love
Owners: Patrina and Bruce Odette, Lindsay Van Keuren, Lorrie Carlton and Larry Letsche DVM
Breeders: Lindsay Van Keuren, G. Blue, Lorrie Carlton and Larry Letsche DVM
Handler: Bill McFadden
Judge: Betty-Anne Stenmark
Now nine years old, Flynn lives with his breeder-owners, Lorrie Carlton and her veterinarian-husband Larry Letsche, in Plymouth, Michigan. Carlton cheerfully reports that Flynn is “totally girl crazy,” and with fruitful results: This irresistible powderpuff of a dog has sired 16 champions to date, with several more pointed. When the other canines in the house need reminding about who’s boss, Flynn is quick to oblige, but “in a nice way,” Carlton says – mostly by marking. Belly band time!
Flynn travels every day to Letsche’s veterinary clinic (with occasional outings to the bank and local coffee shop), luxuriating in his own personalized dog bed made for him by a client. “Before Covid, he would delight in having the clients come in and pet him along with taking cell-phone pictures,” Carlton says. And now that dog shows are gearing up again, Flynn is back on the road as a perennial sidekick. “He has gone to almost every show we have gone to, and heaven forbid he doesn't get to stay on a table to meet and greet people,” she says. And when Flynn’s not at dog shows, or showing off to his admirers? “He’s just a normal dog.”
GCHB King Arthur Van Foliny Home
Wire Fox Terrier
Owner: Victor Malzoni Jr.
Breeders: Rony De Munter and Dieny Uiterwijk
Handler: Gabriel Rangel
Judge: Peter Green
King’s victory two years ago was perfectly on trend for his breed: Wire Fox Terriers have always been the winningest dogs at Westminster, ending up as top dog 15 times out of 112 shows, or almost 10 percent of the time.
For his part, this Belgian-born wire arrived on this side of the Atlantic with an already sterling show record, having won the Terrier Group at the uber-prestigious World Dog Show in 2014 and again in 2015.
After his 2019 triumph, King retired with owners Victor and Susan Malzoni. They report that he is a “very energetic and happy” soul that loves to play with their other house dogs. In the non-platonic department, he’s produced promising puppies in several countries. And as for the humans in the household, he prefers them to be homebodies like him, gently pulling them back by the pants leg if they attempt to leave.
GCHP Stone Run Afternoon Tea
Owners/breeders: Connie Unger and William Lee
Handler: Chrystal Murray-Clas
Judge: Robert H. Slay
Like their human counterparts, bitches on the show circuit inevitably delay having little ones until their career goals are achieved. So it should come as no surprise that after some running around in 2020 – literally, as she earned two legs of her Fast Cat title last year – a more casually coiffed Siba became a mother of eight this April.
“Siba is my shadow, and wants to be and go with me everywhere,” says breeder-owner Connie Unger, whose Northampton, Pennsylvania, home has a custom-ordered mailbox topper featuring a silhouette of Siba performing her signature ringside bow. “She is the perfect companion.”
Though she hasn’t been shown in more than a year, Siba is still a top-five Poodle and so received an invite to this year’s Westminster. She won’t be in attendance – she’ll be on the sofa with a pig’s ear, thank you – but you can find her front and center in the show’s 2021 commemorative painting, with Lyndhurst mansion as the backdrop.